Barrotta’s Supper Club

Avis sur le restaurant Barrotta’s Supper Club de personnes qui y ont mangé. Basés sur les notes récentes.

1. M

   Maria

   New York1 avis

   5.0

   Y est allé·e il y a 1 jour

   1. Global 5
   2. Plats 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Atmosphère 5

   Attentive staff and deliciously prepared food was enhanced by the live music (keyboard player). Since our reservation was for a Sunday evening, the restaurant did not impose the 2-hour limit which they have in place for Friday & Saturday evenings. An overall wonderful experience!
   

   Cet avis est-il utile ?

2. K

   Karen VIP

   New York7 avis

   2.0

   Y est allé·e le il y a 2 jours

   1. Global 2
   2. Plats 2
   3. Service 4
   4. Atmosphère 3

   We recently dined at Barrotta’s Supper Club drawn in by the buzz surrounding this new spot and, more importantly, by my husband’s love for jazz. The live jazz music was a great touch and added to the ambiance, but unfortunately, the dining experience fell short of expectations. We brought a bottle of wine and requested a decanter, only to be told they didn’t have any available because they were all in use. That was disappointing, as a well-run restaurant should have enough for its guests. For appetizers, I ordered the crab cake, which tasted frozen and overly processed—far from the fresh, flavorful dish we had hoped for. As for my entrée, I ordered the Beef Wellington, requesting it to be cooked medium rare. Despite this, it arrived medium. A friend had previously warned me about her own experience with this dish, but I wanted to give the restaurant the benefit of the doubt. Sadly, it turned out she was right. For a side, I ordered the lobster mac and cheese, which was also underwhelming. It was mostly pasta with just two pieces of lobster, lacking the richness and flavor I expected. On a positive note, our server, Fabio, was great—attentive and friendly, which made the experience more pleasant. The cocktail drinks were okay but nothing particularly memorable. Dessert was a highlight, though—the chocolate flourless cake was delicious. However, the restaurant didn’t offer coffee or espresso, which was disappointing, especially for a pre-fixe menu. Overall, for the price of the pre-fixe menu, it wasn’t worth it. While the jazz music and service were enjoyable, the food didn’t live up to expectations, and I don’t anticipate returning.
   

   Cet avis est-il utile ?

3. P

   Peter VIP

   Orlando13 avis

   3.0

   Y est allé·e le il y a 2 jours

   1. Global 3
   2. Plats 1
   3. Service 5
   4. Atmosphère 3

   The service and the music were great. The food was not near the expected quality.
   

   Cet avis est-il utile ?

4. j

   jeanne VIP

   New York16 avis

   5.0

   Y est allé·e le il y a 4 jours

   1. Global 5
   2. Plats 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Atmosphère 5

   Always a wonderful time at Barrotta's Supper Club. I took my Aunt and Uncle there for their 1st time and they loved everything. Food, wine and the service.
   

   Cet avis est-il utile ?

5. p

   phil

   New York1 avis

   5.0

   Y est allé·e le 8 mars 2025

   1. Global 5
   2. Plats 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Atmosphère 5

   Great experience, first time there for anniversary. Real comfy, quaint and nice vibe. Food was excellent and staff great. Nice for date nite or group of friends. Jazz band nice bonus.
   

   Cet avis est-il utile ?

6. M

   Mike

   New York4 avis

   2.0

   Y est allé·e le 8 mars 2025

   1. Global 2
   2. Plats 2
   3. Service 4
   4. Atmosphère 2

   I wanted to love it as it’s a great idea and great addition to Huntington but I feel they missed on multiple areas. Especially on the value. Way to expensive for what is was.
   

   Cet avis est-il utile ?

7. C

   Carlos

   New York1 avis

   5.0

   Y est allé·e le 8 mars 2025

   1. Global 5
   2. Plats 4
   3. Service 5
   4. Atmosphère 5

   Great place , great music , ambiance and food. Jazz was awesome . It was a refreshing change from your usual restaurant
   

   Cet avis est-il utile ?

8. J

   Julie VIP

   New York15 avis

   5.0

   Y est allé·e le 7 mars 2025

   1. Global 5
   2. Plats 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Atmosphère 4

   Excellent food! Outstanding music! Extremely attentive service! Really enjoyed and highly recommend!
   

   Cet avis est-il utile ?

9. A

   Ashley

   New York6 avis

   5.0

   Y est allé·e le 7 mars 2025

   1. Global 5
   2. Plats 5
   3. Service 5
   4. Atmosphère 5

   Incredible food, incredible service. Best restaurant we’ve been to in a while!
   

   Cet avis est-il utile ?

10. L

    Linda VIP

    New York11 avis

    1.0

    Y est allé·e le 1 mars 2025

    1. Global 1
    2. Plats 1
    3. Service 1
    4. Atmosphère 4

    Over priced Food was mediocre waiter upsells everything and music too loud
    

    Cet avis est-il utile ?